The School of Athens Fresco Essay

The School of Athens fresco, commissioned by the pope of its era, is located in the Vatican. The room housing this masterpiece contains four frescoes representing justice, theology, poetry, and philosophy. Their placement reflects the Renaissance view of education, where theology and philosophy, as well as justice and poetry, were seen as complementary disciplines. This essay focuses on the School of Athens, also known as the Philosophy Fresco.

Creation and Central Figures

Painted between 1509 and 1511 by Raphael (Raffaello Sanzio), the fresco features philosophers and scientists from various eras at its center, flanked by statues of two Greek gods.

• At the center stand Plato and Aristotle, whose gestures symbolize their contrasting philosophies:

  • Plato, on the left, points upward, representing his focus on the metaphysical world of ideals.

  • Aristotle, on the right, gestures downward, emphasizing the tangible, material world.

The fresco is divided into two sides:

• Plato’s side features figures aligned with his idealist worldview.

• Aristotle’s side includes followers of his empirical and materialist approach.

Notable Figures in the Fresco

1. Socrates

   • Positioned on Plato’s side, Socrates is shown in heated discussion, embodying his Socratic method of questioning and debate.

2. Alexander the Great

   • Found on Plato’s side, Alexander’s education by Aristotle reflects the link between philosophy and rulership.

   • Despite his short reign, Alexander’s conquests and philosophical upbringing solidified his legacy.

3. Hypatia

   • Subtly depicted as the pope’s niece, Hypatia was the first known female scientist and philosopher.

   • She contributed to mathematics alongside her father but faced a tragic death due to religious opposition.

4. Pythagoras

   • Famous for his contributions to mathematics, Pythagoras revered numbers with almost religious fervor.

   • His belief in the universe's mathematical harmony remains influential despite his dogmatic tendencies.

5. Averroes (Ibn Rushd)

   • A prominent Muslim scholar, Averroes’s interpretations of Aristotle were instrumental in igniting the European Renaissance.

6. Heraclitus

   • Added later to the fresco, Heraclitus is shown in a melancholic pose.

   • Known as the philosopher of change, he famously declared, “You cannot step into the same river twice.”

7. Diogenes

   • Representing Cynicism, Diogenes lived in rejection of material wealth.

   • His famous reply to Alexander the Great, “Stand out of my sunlight,” symbolizes his disdain for power and riches.

8. Euclid

   • As the Father of Geometry, Euclid is depicted teaching with compasses.

   • His work, Elements, influenced science and mathematics for over two millennia.

9. Ptolemy

   • Holding a globe, Ptolemy represents his contributions to geography and astronomy.

   • Despite later disproven ideas, his work profoundly impacted exploration and scientific thought.

10. Zoroaster

• With a celestial globe, Zoroaster symbolizes monotheism and moral duality.

• His position opposite Ptolemy reflects their differing cosmic views.

11. Apelles (Self-Portrait of Raphael)

• Raphael included himself as Apelles, an ancient Greek painter.

• Facing the viewer directly, Raphael’s self-portrait nods to the Renaissance tradition of self-representation.

Conclusion

The School of Athens showcases not just the figures it portrays but also the Renaissance ideals of harmonizing diverse fields of knowledge. By featuring thinkers from different eras and philosophies, the fresco embodies a timeless celebration of curiosity, debate, and intellectual pursuit.

We hope this exploration has deepened your appreciation for art, history, and philosophy, inspiring you to engage critically and lead a questioning life.

Written by Betül Ebrar Özdemir
Edited by Rüzgar Kaçmaz

Türkçesi için tıklayınız.